Category

Questions

9 questions

QST-0001Question

How should 'prior context is not evidence' be scoped so it doesn't contradict the archive?

OriginAI GeneratedStatusTentative

The instruction says previous conversations, memories, patterns, and assumptions are not evidence for the current situation. The archive's purpose is to accumulate prior material as evidence. Proposed resolution (needs…

QST-0002Question

Is `source` a canonical object type or infrastructure?

OriginAI GeneratedStatusTentative

The canon lists 11 object types; the data spec defines 12, adding `source` (the pointer to raw artifacts, with file path and hash). Options: (a) amend the canon to 12 types; (b) keep `source` out of the canon as…

QST-0003Question

What does 'long-term consistency' mean as an AI priority?

OriginAI GeneratedStatusTentative

Prioritizing long-term consistency can collide with 'never defend previous conclusions for consistency alone' (prn-0005). Proposed reading: consistency of structure, terminology, and provenance discipline — explicitly…

QST-0004Question

How do I pursue truth without becoming dogmatic?

OriginHuman InterpretationStatusTentative

Source: src-0003#A7, black marker, board center. Board text is cut at the photo edge after "Dog…" — completion "dogmatic" is [uncertain] though high confidence. First-person on the board ("how do I…"), preserved as…

QST-0005Question

Is music discovered, created, or revealed?

OriginHuman InterpretationStatusTentative

Source: src-0004#B2 (corroborated src-0005#C3-1), dark blue, upper-left of Board B state 1. Verbatim. A three-way framing, not binary — the board offers discovery, creation, and revelation as distinct options.

QST-0006Question

What if music is the exp[ression?] of relationship itself?

OriginHuman InterpretationStatusTentative

Source: src-0004#B3 (corroborated src-0005#C3-2), light blue. Board reads verbatim "What if music is the exp of relationship itself?" — "exp" is [uncertain: expression? experience? experiment?]. Chance should resolve…

QST-0007Question

What kind of environment should exist for creative people?

OriginHuman InterpretationStatusTentative

Source: src-0004#B4, purple, board center. Red annotation beneath "People": "← free range →" — a candidate answer attached to the question (free-range conditions rather than managed ones) [interpretation]. Directly…

QST-0008Question

What is authentic creativity?

OriginHuman InterpretationStatusTentative

Source: src-0004#B6, black, boxed for emphasis, drawn beside the mission statement's key term "Authentic Creativity". The box placement makes this the mission's own load-bearing open question: the mission (prn-0012)…

QST-0009Question

Which wording of the PG mission is current, and what did flourish → emerge → discovered/expressed/shared change?

OriginAI GeneratedStatusTentative

src-0004#B5 shows two red strike-throughs ("flourish", "emerge") inside the mission statement. The final reading is [uncertain in word order]. Needs Chance: (1) confirm the current canonical wording; (2) record why each…